Skip to main content

The bad and the lot more good of Benni

There is good and bad in Benni McCarthy’s altercation with Bidvest Wits’ players and staff after the Telkom Knockout final at Durban’s Moses Mabhida stadium last Saturday.
Firstly, it was bad for him to remonstrate with his former Bafana Bafana teammate and now Wits assistant coach Eric Tinkler. Benni had raised Tinkler’s ire when he “trampled” on defender Sipho Mngomezulu.
When he left the pitch when he was substituted with Pirates already 3-1, McCarthy made a disparaging gesture towards the Wits bench, apparently to taunt his ex-Bafana mate. Then at final whistle a victorious Benni boisterously threw expletives at Tinkler, and had to be restrained by Pirates’ staff.
Even doubly bad was McCarthy’s rejection of the mandatory post-match handshake attempt by Wits striker Ryan Chapman. He alleged lashed out at Chapman, forgetting that the aspiring young striker is a homeboy from Cape Town, who grew up idolizing him at the height of his international career.
He was on Chapmans’ case the whole week ahead of the final match. Personally I thought it was good brinkmanship helping the hype around the big match.
However for both incidents, Benni gets zero for sportsmanship. He set a bad example for children watching at the stadium and more at home in front of their TVs. He’s too smart to go down this way so I hope he will have a different take on the matter when the dust settles down, and do the right thing.
The most magnanimous thing I hope to see him do is for him to visit Chapman and apologise – and, of course, shake his hand.  
McCarthy’s outrage also has some positives, if you look closely enough.  Well, the first good I have already candidly referred to above, about him helping to sell the game. PSL players are generally mutes who contribute nothing towards selling matches as they virtually have nothing to say. Even when they do open their mouths, what comes out is a forgettable murmur that would probably send fans and opposition to sleep than inject an adrenalin rush ahead of coming hostilities.
So, in my book, McCarthy did well in the run up of the Telkom Knockout to sell the game with his bombastic and cocky approach. He said Wits would pay for the 3-1 drubbing they gave the Buccaneers a little over two weeks earlier. He also used some psychological mumbo-jumbo to numb Chapman, who in the run up to the final, was the hottest striker in the country.
So the public wanted to see this, how “loudmouth” Benni himself would shape up in the final match. The stadium was sold out and taverns and other watching venues were overflowing, not only with Pirates supporters and Wits sympathizers, but with soccer fans from all persuasions of the beautiful game. You did it Benni.
Another good is that Benni is bringing a new mentality into the Bucs camp, a fighting spirit. Pirates won the treble last season without McCarthy, which means they knew how to win. They also fought back bravely several occasions to avoid defeats – mostly forcing late-minute draws. Benni McCarthy is saying this game is not for sissies – the fight to win is not over even after the final whistle. This is the attitude Pirates players are going to need if they wish to keep the momentum going for a long time. And more than that, they are going to need this mentality when their campaign in the CAF Champions League begin later in February.
Many SA teams have complained of tough conditions when out playing on the continent. Of course Africa is tough, and we know that full well because its our continent and we grew up here. The lack of fighting back against hostility on their travels is what has kept SA teams far from the honours table in African football for a long time.
So, like him or loathe him, Benni is here to kick butt and that’s what the PSL and Orlando Pirates need to step up.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Rest in peace Zet, thanks for the good times

Legends. . . Zithulele Sinqe runs ahead of another roadrunning super star Willie Mtolo in 1986 Each time when I drive past ERPM in Boksburg, along Rondebult Road, one name springs to mind: Ernest Seleke. The association comes from the memory of Seleke running in a vest with ERPM emblazoned across the chest area. Back then, in the 1980s, I did not even know that ERPM was an abbreviation for a mine, and that the initials stood for East Rand Propriety Mine. To me ERPM was Seleke, not the gold mine it actually was. Stock, as the lithe running machine was known, was a marvel to watch on TV during that time of my schooldays. However, he was not alone among the crop of SA runners who were nurtured and sponsored by the mines to excel in their sport – both on track and on the road – at that time. There were many products of the mines and parastatals but I can immediately single out Xolile Yawa, Matthew Temane, Gibeon Moshaba, Matthew Batswadi, Ben Choeu and much later Zithulele Sin...

Broos returns respect and the swag to Bafana

When Hugo Broos was announced in May 2021 as the new manager of the South African national football team, the news was received by sneers and jeers if not completely ignored by some of those it affected the most - the SA soccer fraternity. At the time Bafana Bafana, the national team, had not long been labelled a "bunch of losers" by the sports minister Fikile Mbalula. His words cut like a blunt knife, even though the truth is that Bafana were at the time hopeless and lacked confidence. It was fair-game for anyone, including the lowest-ranked nations, to meet Bafana because the chances of scoring a victory over the SA team were real and attainable. So, more than the sports minister, the nation was despondent over Bafana circumstances. Even Broos appointment, despite his known success on the continent, was slammed as that of an old man chasing an easy retirement fund. It was a tough job from the start for the Belgian - having to rouse the players from a comatose of low sel...

The enemy within at Kaizer Chiefs

The new Premier Soccer League in South Africa is in its third week and already there's trouble at one of the biggest clubs, Kaizer Chiefs. The upheaval stems from within, thanks to the club's restless supporters. Restless is an understatement to describe a largely belligerent horde ready to trash and clobber, as they showed once again at Mbombela on Sunday 20 August after losing to TS Galaxy. Chiefs are not winning matches because they are goal-shy, scoring just 1 goal in their opening three matches of the league. That is not the scoring rate to win football matches. But instead of directing their anger to the team's forwards, and to some extent the rest of the outfield players, the supporters are blaming the coach and the goalkeeper. Chiefs No 1 keeper Brandon Peterson is a having a torrid time from the fans, despite his form saving the team from serious embarassment game after game. Against Galaxy last week a stopped four certain goal attempts, and earlier in the month...