Skip to main content

Caleb or Shalulile, SA football loses

Bonfils-Caleb Bimenyimana


Earlier this week the suppoters of two of South Africa's biggest clubs, Mamelodi Sundowns and Kaizer Chiefs, engaged in a duel of wits which trended on Twitter about who between the two clubs' top strikers was going to win the local league's Golden Boot. 

While Sundowns followers vouched for their goalgetter Peter Shalulile, the Chiefs legion punted their new striker Bonfils-Caleb Bimenyimana. 

Namibian international Shalulile is the hottest goalpoacher in the South African league for the past three season for the champion club Sundowns, while the lanky Burundian simply known as Caleb is still new in the league. The pair is locked at 6 goals apiece at the top of the league charts, after 9 matches for Shalulile and after 10 matches for Caleb.

My response to the debate is that, both Shalulile and Caleb add value to their clubs and the league but at the end of the day - or the current season in the context of the scoring race - whoever wins between the two, SA football loses.

It loses because the poor scoring rate by South African players would be extended to another level. The difficulty of this situation can be seen with the poor fortunes of the national team Bafana Bafana. Despite the South African Premier League (aka PSL) being touted as one of the best leagues around, whatever that means, the physical evidence is far from the claim. 

Next month the Fifa World Cup kickoffs in Qatar and South Africa is not one of the five countries representing Africa there. Fair enough, Cameroon, Ghana, Morocco, Senegal and Tunisia did not qualify entirely based of the strength of their national leagues. They had mostly benefitted from fine talent based in top leagues in Europe, with some of the players even born and developed by better equipped structures in European countries.

But it is also the truth that many of those overseas-based African players in the 5 African national teams in the 2022 Qatar World Cup worked their way up to the top leagues, from their towns and villages and clubs in Africa. 

So, if the PSL is one of the finest leagues around, why it's South African-born players battle to attract the attention of big clubs in Europe? 

The fairness of the question can be seen through the fact that South Africa does not feature in the next CHAN tournament to be hosted by Algeria in January 2023. CHAN is an African championships played by senior national teams consisting of players campaigning in their domestic leagues. For the record, SA's Bafana Bafana are habitually eliminated in the qualifying rounds and this time were kicked out by Angola via a humiliating 4-1 aggregate score last month.

This outcome clearly means the Angolan Girabola is stronger that the PSL. Angola therefore joins host Algeria, Congo, Mali, Ghana, Ethiopia, Niger, Uganda, Senegal, Mauritania, Madagascar, Sudan, Libya,  Morocco (two-time defending champion), Mozambique, DR Congo, Cameroon, Ivory Coast in the final tournament.

Even in the CAF club championships, clubs from Morocco and Tunisia and fellow North African neighbours Algeria and Egypt,regularly produce results that are far better than the PSL clubs can manage.

Last season, PSL powerhouse Orlando Pirates did well to reach the CAF Confederation Cup final. But they were reduced to runners-up by Berkane, until a decade ago an unfashionable regional club from Morocco. 

The woes of South Africa in international football are rooted in so many wrong things about the PSL. Above struggling with getting the basic techniques right, goalscoring has become like rocket science in the PSL.

I will use the two matches playing today to illustrate my point: Orlando Pirates vs AmaZulu and Golden Arrows vs Stellenbosch. 

Pirates have not scored a goal in their last 3 matches - two league and 1 cup; AmaZulu are winless in their last 5 league matches due to their poor scoring form. Both clubs are desperate for goals in order to win tonight. However, a reasonable punter will bet for a safe but sad 0-0. 

In Durban, hosts Arrows and their vistors are not doing great either in the scoring charts, with rates of 1.2 (from 9 matches) and 1.3 (10 matches) respectively so far. 

I appreciate Shalulile and Caleb very much because of the excitement they bring to the game. However, SA football has a bigger task in its hands to produce similarly reliable, prolific strikers. Without accomplishing this task, and others that are urgent about South African football, our game is heading nowhere. 

Peter Shalulile


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rest in peace Zet, thanks for the good times

Legends. . . Zithulele Sinqe runs ahead of another roadrunning super star Willie Mtolo in 1986 Each time when I drive past ERPM in Boksburg, along Rondebult Road, one name springs to mind: Ernest Seleke. The association comes from the memory of Seleke running in a vest with ERPM emblazoned across the chest area. Back then, in the 1980s, I did not even know that ERPM was an abbreviation for a mine, and that the initials stood for East Rand Propriety Mine. To me ERPM was Seleke, not the gold mine it actually was. Stock, as the lithe running machine was known, was a marvel to watch on TV during that time of my schooldays. However, he was not alone among the crop of SA runners who were nurtured and sponsored by the mines to excel in their sport – both on track and on the road – at that time. There were many products of the mines and parastatals but I can immediately single out Xolile Yawa, Matthew Temane, Gibeon Moshaba, Matthew Batswadi, Ben Choeu and much later Zithulele Sin
1 comment
Read more

Memphis shows how far we have fallen

Against all odds. . . Dutch forward Memphis Depay overcame a difficult childhood to shine on world stage. One of the unlikely stars of the Netherlands squad at the 2014 World Cup in Brazil is without a doubt winger Memphis Depay. He is used sparingly in the Dutch team, usually coming on as a second half substitute. The reason for that is clear: Depay is still being developed for big things in future. He started playing regularly at his club PSV Eindhoven only from last season. Secondly, he only turned 20 in February this year, so he still needs protected, gradual introduction to the senior national team. And after just eight caps for Oranje, he's doing all-right. Though the factors above are important to note, it is Depay's childhood which is more crucial to mention. He grew up without a father after his Ghanaian immigrant father left the family following divorce from Memphis' mother. Depay refers to this episode in his life by insisting to be called just Memphis,
Post a Comment
Read more

The enemy within at Kaizer Chiefs

The new Premier Soccer League in South Africa is in its third week and already there's trouble at one of the biggest clubs, Kaizer Chiefs. The upheaval stems from within, thanks to the club's restless supporters. Restless is an understatement to describe a largely belligerent horde ready to trash and clobber, as they showed once again at Mbombela on Sunday 20 August after losing to TS Galaxy. Chiefs are not winning matches because they are goal-shy, scoring just 1 goal in their opening three matches of the league. That is not the scoring rate to win football matches. But instead of directing their anger to the team's forwards, and to some extent the rest of the outfield players, the supporters are blaming the coach and the goalkeeper. Chiefs No 1 keeper Brandon Peterson is a having a torrid time from the fans, despite his form saving the team from serious embarassment game after game. Against Galaxy last week a stopped four certain goal attempts, and earlier in the month
Post a Comment
Read more